Been here a few times! The food is great! The lobster rolls are.... Lobster rolls. I'm no connoisseur, but the rolls were good. My only gripe is you need to ASK MARKET PRICE BEFORE ORDERING. It's a simple sandwich with a high cost if you're not prepared to hear it. That being said it was great the pictures are from my second time there, my first I got a lobster roll, chips and we had ice cream dessert. Decor is gorgeous, it's never too crowded when we go.

I love a good seafood establishment! Peacemaker was in a cute neighborhood where parking was a bit difficult since you had to find a spot on the street. There was a lot of seating inside and it was beautifully decorated. The venue had great options but I was surprised they didn't have crab cakes! I got the shrimp po boy and it was delicious. I was only able to eat half if it so it was a nice size. There is an option to get lobster bisque worh or without the added lobster meat which was good! Of course it was more expensive to add lobster. If I was just having the bisque as my meal I would have added it for sure. The lobster roll was full of meaty lobster and was so good! Our server was very nice and helpful! We weren't sure which frozen drink to get so she offered us a little sample of a few to help us decide which was nice. It was an overall good experience.

While I have quite a few critiques about my experience here, I can't deny that the food was phenomenal. Favorite dishes: Shrimp poorboy, lobster mac

Peacemaker is the bomb. This Benton Park staple consistently delivers fresh, flown-in-daily seafood that makes you forget you're in a landlocked city. Bless you Kevin Nashan. While I couldn't personally join this time, my trusted seafood enthusiasts, Jensen and Ace, held down the fort--and look at these videos Look at that buttery lobster. Peacemaker offers a menu that feels like a mini coastal getaway. Their oysters are pristine, the clam chowder comforting, the crab roll a lunch staple, and then there's the lobster. All are pure magic. Even pescatarians with the highest standards (read: me) can rely on Peacemaker for exceptional quality and variety. #StLouisPescatarianApproved Always!

OMG! Looks are definitely deceiving. I didn't expect this restaurant to be this big on the inside from the way it looked on the outside. The staff were so nice. The Margarita and lobster roll were exceptional. My only complaint is I needed a bigger lobster roll! I could eat that sandwich everyday, all day! I'm going back soon!

Went on a weeknight for dinner which was not busy. Exceptional and attentive service. We started with oysters and lobster bisque (lobster added), shared the Connecticut style lobster roll and Maine style lobster roll for entree, and got the s'mores dessert. We ordered the lobster rolls even though they were $36 each (market price that day), was a bit nervous at first about value for what we were paying, but worth every dollar. They also had a really good music playlist playing throughout the dining rooms. They have a bar and main dining area.

WOW! Finally checked this 2 year wishlist restaurant off of my list :) my partner surprised me with dinner where for my birthday and it was nothing short of amazing. We had a beer and wine in the cute, chick restaurant. For dinner, I couldn't decide which lobster roll I wanted so I ordered both! Tbh, I'm more of a Maine style as I like the cold lobster with the mayo and greens on top vs the very buttery Connecticut roll. Both were delicious tho! My partner ordered a poboy and loved it too. Definitely going back :) also shout out our the server who made it a great experience!

Took my boyfriend here for his 30th birthday and my oh myyyy. I literally ate a whole pound of crab legs and didn't even need the butter it was THAT good. My boyfriend got the whole lobster and ate the entire thing as well. We were enjoying ourselves so much we were already planning another date night to go back. I'd like to add that we had excellent service!!

I finally tried something other than the Connecticut style lobster roll, so a review update is in order! While the lobster roll is still fantastic as ever, I tried the buffalo crawfish poorboy and I'm obsessed! Not only is it delicious, but it's also a good size. I was able to take one of the sandwich halves home and it was just as good the next day! I also love starting off with oysters! They're fresh and always have a few different kinds to choose And kudos to Peacemaker for the continually stellar service. The servers always go the extra mile with their kindness, and I appreciate it so much!

A classy place to dine for seafood. The staff was attentive during the busy lunch hour on Father's Day. We had reservations and were seated promptly. The catfish, shrimp, and lobster were good. The shrimp is a must to order! Our favorite was the 4 Hands Peacemaker beer that complemented the seafood. I could not find a kid's menu online or was given one when we arrived. I settled with ordering my toddler french fries. The waitress volunteered items for kids and we went with the mac and cheese. The blueberry dessert was delightful. The hint of graham crackers was my biggest takeaway from it being a tasty sweet treat.